Blog #5
Democratic Senator Max Baucus of Montana has recently
decided not to run for reelection. In a
recent New York Times article the author Janet Hook writes of Baucus’s
announcement on March 23rd. His retirement makes the total number six on
the list of retiring Democratic Senators.
In recent votes concerning the budget and gun control legislation,
Baucus has gone against the party. Baucus
wants to reform the tax code to make it simpler without raising revenue, in
clear opposition to several members of his party that want to simplify the tax
code while also raising revenue (that they intend to do by increasing the
income taxes on the wealthiest Americans.)
It will be interesting to see how the remainder of his term plays
out. Now that Baucus is not trying to
get reelected will his voting record continue to be in opposition to his party
beliefs or will he switch sides in support of his fellow Democrats. We will all be on the edge of our seats with
curiosity and anticipation I’m sure.
Video with Discussion
on his Retirement Choice:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HIkaEZjvts
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HIkaEZjvts
Even though Baucus is not running again it is useful to see
how he is scored and rated amongst interest groups, his party, and the
DW-Nominate committee to better understand his positions on particular
issues. Alterations to Baucus’s voting
preferences may lead to a change in these current scores. Whether or not a member of Congress votes
with or against the standard party position can have effects on their authority
within the institution and have a positive or a negative effect on the opinions
of a member’s constituency. According
to Open Congress Baucus voted with the Democratic Party 75% of the time, which
ranked 51st out of the 53 Senators.
Interest groups have the ability to sway a member to vote in their favor
if the particular interest group has a strong standing in the member’s
constituency. Montana is a rather
conservative state, supporting Romney in the 2012 election by 14 points over
President Obama. The interest groups
ratings that are important for Baucus include, but are not limited to,
NARAL-Pro Choice America, Planned Parenthood, National Farmers Union, American
Civil Liberties Union, NRA, and for fun The Federally Employed Women. It is relevant to notice the change in
ratings over the years of Baucus’s congressional service. I should mention that the following information
is given in percentages. The higher the
percentage the more often Baucus votes in accordance with that interest group’s
views. THE NARAL-Pro Choice America and
Planned Parenthood ratings mirror each other giving Baucus a 100% rating in
both the year 2010 and the year 2000.
The face that Baucus is consistently a Pro Choice supporter in a rather
conservative state is surprising to me.
The National Farmers Union gave Baucus a 100% in both 2010 and
2000. The American Civil Liberties Union
gave Baucus an 80% approval rating in the year 2010 and just a 57% approval
rating in the year 2000. The NRA (who is considered to be one of the most
powerful and influential interest groups in America today) has an interesting
report on Senator Baucus. In the year
2008, which was the most recent rating I found, they gave the Senator
100%. But in the year 2002 he received
only a 67% and even more surprising 0% in 1993.
The recent votes and actions taken by Baucus in accordance with NRA
views are obviously in due to push from his constituency (there must be a good number of Ted Nugent want-to-Bes in Montana). http://dailycaller.com/2012/12/27/flashback-ted-nugent-to-piers-morgan-on-gun-control-kiss-my-ass-video/
(Nugent on gun control) The ADA (Americans
for Democratic Action) gave Baucus and 85% rating this year. DW-Nominate ranked Baucus 45th of
101 Senators in the 112th Congress and 52nd in the 111th
Congress.
Sources:
http://www.voteview.com/SENATE_SORT112.HTM
(used for DW-Nominate scores)
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324235304578440651803014518.html
(This is a NY Times article announcing Baucus’s retirement Tuesday)
http://www.adaction.org/media/2011%20ADA%20Voting%20Record(1).pdf
(Used to score members on their action vs. inaction in Congress)
http://votesmart.org/candidate/53315/max-baucus#.UXlHEaI3uSo
(List of various interest group ratings)
http://www.opencongress.org/people/show/300005_Max_Baucus
(Used for party rating)